Shanpu switches

 I got a shipment of sample switches from Shanpu in Taipei today. I had to pay full DHL express freight but they were very nice and sent me the samples for free. I will be able to buy directly from them in multiples of 100 of each item, and the price ends up at around $1.4 per switch including cap, but shipping and a rather steep low-volume fee of $100 for orders below 1000 means the real cost is closer to $3-4 depending on the number of switches I buy.

There are several switches to choose from. All are rated at 1,000,000 cycles!

The SPH2S has an audible click and a short travel of 0.2 to 0.3mm, 190 +/- 50gf force

The SPH2T has a very audible click and a medium long travel of 0.4 to 0.6mm, 230 +/- 50gf

The SPH2N has a no audible click and a very long travel of 1.0 to 1.4mm, 60 +/- 40gf

Then there is a low profile version, but it is only rated for 100,000 cycles, so unless it is more suitable due to the low profile, I should really go for one of the others.

The SPFSP1 has an audible click and a short travel of 0.2 to 0.4mm, 200 +/- 50gf force

In some ways I like the N version best, it sits somewhere between the keyboard switch feel of the Nord keyboards and the normal clicky synth button. It doesn't feel quite right somehow though, it's like the travel is a bit too short or something.

The T is a bit too noisy for me, so that leaves me with the S. The click feel of the S is closest to the D50 when comparing to some of my synths. It is a little bit on the heavy side though, switching between it and the N makes me think I like the feel of the N better.

But then there is another issue - caps.

I ordered six different caps in four different designs

YCA085C, a 9.6mm round, transparent black cap with a "lense" effect on top. It turns out that it is glossy, and because of the way it has been made, with a hole in the center, the light is rather uneven. Not too much, but it is not the best.

YCA151A, same as YCA085C, but one mm shorter and Ice color (translucent white). The light is much better, but this may simply be because more light gets through due to the color, or it is because it is 1mm shorter. I have to retest the black one with a smaller diode. Of course, its white when switched off, so it will not blend into the design if I choose a black front panel.

YCA080C, an 8mm round transparent black cap. It has a more frosted look and is flat on top. It looks really great and the light is much better too. It has ONE major drawback though, and that is that it's only 3.3mm long. If I use a 3mm panel, or a long travel switch, it is simply too small for me. It's really a shame, because it's hands down the winner when it comes to looks. Oh, and it would be a perfect match for the 8mm black alu 

YCA059C, an oval transparent black. It is too small for my liking.

YCA044A, a square, 7.5mm ice white cap with a slightly rounded top. It looks good, but is too thin, and the led is clearly visible through, so I can't use it.

YCA043C, a square, 7.5mm transparent black cap with flat top. Unfortunately it is simply too transparent and completely useless. It WOULD however make a perfect base for glueing the black 8mm alu caps on top of, if I want to use them with the same switches. I may even use them for the red square Aliexpress caps.

Bonus test: The red square aliexpress caps look ok with the led, though they have an internal pattern that is very visible. It doesn't really look like they are meant to be backlit.

That means that I'm probably down to two options: The biggest round transparent black cap with whatever switch I like the best, or the 8mm round cap with the S-model switch and a thinner panel. I must test if I can get away with 2mm aluminum.

Update:

1 - There is an even better option for attaching aluminum caps: They sell a 5mm round cap, YCA052, which probably will fit very well inside the aluminum - perhaps with a 1mm gap that could possibly be filled with glue? There is also a 6mm one, YCA046. Perhaps I should buy both just to check. BTW: The top of the alu cap may be too thick for this option, but the extra cost of buying 100 caps is so little that it would be stupid not to do so.

2 - For the switches where the led will NOT be used, it would be possible to put a piece of black cardboard inside and coloring the edges of the cap holder black to get a much darker cap - the white parts shine through and making the insides black helped a lot.

3 - changing from a 270Ohm to a 150Ohm for the thicker transparent black cap helps. Still not as good as the other though, so I definitely have to test 2mm aluminum panels.